David Fincher's 'The Social Network' is part revenge story, part courtroom drama, part "rise/fall" success story, and part commentary on the new millenium's new kind of young internet entrepreneur. Fincher and screenwriter Aaron Sorkin paint Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg as an angry reject, a tireless workhorse, a backstabbing friend, and a condescending genius. "You're not an asshole, Mark", Rashida Jones's sympathetic attorney tells him. "You just try so hard to be". Zuckerberg's rage, according to Sorkin (who adapted the script from Ben Mezrich's novel), seems to stem from what we could safely assume is a lifetime of social rejection. He's unattractive, hyper-focused on his academic career, uncool, and surrounded by the beautiful people at Harvard.
'The Social Network' opens with Zuckerberg getting dumped by his cute girlfriend after he spends their time at the campus watering hole condescending to her and steering every conversation in the direction of his fixation on getting excepted into an elite, fraternal brotherhood. Genuinely shocked, he immediately walks to his dorm to commence his revenge: a website rating the hotness of the girls at all regional colleges. The development of this site is shown in a montage interspersed with the kind of elite, sexy frat party Zuckerberg would never get invited to. The instant popularity of this site crashes Harvard's entire network in one night, and gains him instant notoriety. He is soon approached by a pair of twin brothers to help them develop an elite social networking site for Harvard's beautiful people. These brothers, the Winklevoss's, are just the kind of Harvard elite that make Zuckerberg feel so unwanted, so unattractive, so marginalized. The kind of guys that his now ex-girlfriend would love to end up with. The kind of guys he would love to destroy by stealing their idea. His legend begins.
The tale of Zuckerberg's rise is told through an initially disorienting flashback arc, where we are at first disoriented over being at multiple depositions, then thrust back at Harvard watching Zuckerberg quickly expand and develop his idea while dodging the Winklevoss's; who slowly learn that their big idea has been robbed by someone smarter. As the film picks up speed, 'The Social Network' becomes a flashback arc explaining why Zuckerberg is being sued by both the Winklevoss's, as well as his best friend and co-Facebook creator, Eduardo Saverin. Though disappointing in its redundancy, it helps Fincher and Sorkin tell an exciting story of the dubious rise of the 21st century entrepreneur: young, smart, and confined to a computer.
Fincher leaves the task of bringing a character like Zuckerberg to the screen with the indie rock-Jew nerd of the day, Jesse Eisenberg. Eisenberg plays Zukerberg like he plays every other character, just like himself - and it works beautifully. His awkward, nervous speaking patterns suit the role of a smarmy, condescending genius; and he doesn't look at all like the kind of guy who gets girls. He succeeds most at being himself, yet managing the face of a young man desperately trying to balance the endless stream of thoughts going through his head. Justin Timberlake continues to redeem his chatchery with another outstanding performance as Sean Parker, the equally nerdy yet far more charming brain behind the rise and fall of Napster. Timberlake's natural charisma suits him well as the guy who dazzled Zuckerberg and helped him make Facebook the cultural standard for social interaction it is today. It also beautifully sets up Parker's addiction to the excesses of success and his resulting, ungraceful exit from the Facebook empire. But the film's best performance comes in the form of Andrew Garfield, who plays Eduardo Saverin as the film's most sympathetic character. Fresh from Harvard, he tries to manage Facebook's business end by the books. Sadly, he falls victim to Zuckerberg's revenge scheming for all the social graces he had that Zuckerberg wasn't blessed with; and can't keep up with this new kind of entrepreneurship.
A few dazzling sequences and his trademark dark-lighting aside, Fincher wisely puts his usual flashiness down here to let the story tell itself; and the results make an otherwise dire story a lot of fun. 'The Social Network''s saddest success is its examination of an intellectually bankrupt generation; a generation with the resources and the smarts to do anything, but with too little inclination to do more than share music and socialize online. People like Sean Parker and Mark Zuckerberg have a gift, but grow up in a time when instant gratification is more important than systematic change. Facebook is cultural phenomenon which crosses generation gaps and keeps people in touch who otherwise wouldn't be, but it also opens the door to people's subconscious inclination to spend more time with their virtual existence and less time with their physical one. The further online social networking progresses, the more Orwell's dystopia seems possible. Now if you'll excuse me, I have to check in to let EVERYONE know where I am.